Note the Maxwell park membership as of last October was 220. They started with less than 100. Growth there has been the result of nothing more than good experiences with the patrol.
The idea is selling itself. -jd
Original Article - http://www.insidebayarea.com/News/ci_24469687/Oakland:-Dimond-District-holds-summit-on
OAKLAND -- Nearly 100 residents gathered at the Dimond Library to hear about the experiences of neighborhoods that have hired private security patrols.
The Oct. 23 event was organized by the Dimond Neighborhood Crime Prevention Council for police beat 22x, which includes the Montera, Woodminster, Lincoln Heights, Oakmore and Dimond neighborhoods. A response to increasing crime and limited police resources in many neighborhoods has been to hire private security patrols.
While these patrols are no substitute for police, they can serve as the eyes and ears of a neighborhood, said Jeff Edman, a steering committee member for the Neighborhood Crime Prevention Council 22x. Many residents feel that their presence has deterred crime.
Resident groups that have organized their neighborhoods from Temescal, Rockridge, Upper Dimond, Oakmore and Maxwell Park shared their experiences about organizing their areas and hiring private patrols.
Doug Drummond, of Oakmore, has created a methodology for organizing neighborhoods that he has shared with neighborhoods around the city. He has helped 13 other neighborhoods organize since April.
"The process is straightforward, but, in reality, it's a lot of work," said Drummond, who spent nearly a year organizing his own neighborhood. "It's all in the planning."
Drummond suggested using websites such as google maps or
nextdoor.com to define the neighborhood.
"A word to the wise, beware of the consequences of not planning ahead. Don't focus on your (immediate) neighborhood and close off the cul-de-sac that has no place to go. Expect gerrymandering," Drummond said.
"The more households you have, the cheaper the services will be. You will need at least 50 percent of the households in your targeted area," he continued. "If it doesn't work, shut it down and try again next year."
That was the experience of another Oakmore neighborhood, near Leimert Boulevard, known as "WTLC", for Waterhouse and Tiffin roads, Leimert Boulevard, and Clemens Road, some of the streets that were in their coverage area.
Organizer Leslie Fisher began to coordinate with her neighbors but abandoned the project in May when she realized she didn't have enough households interested in the idea. She joined forces with an adjacent neighborhood that she met at National Night Out, creating a larger group. The price of services dropped per household, enticing more people to join. Today, they are one of the larger patrol groups in the area.
"They were a small but mighty group. They brought energy to our group," said organizer Karen Richmond, whose neighborhood joined forces with Fisher.
"I feel a sense of ease," Fisher said. "I'm not seeing as much activity on the listservs," indicating that the patrols may have done their job in reducing crime, she said.
Neighborhoods are signing up for a variety of packages offered by different companies, including car and foot patrols, patrols on certain days of the week, random patrols or 24/7 patrols. Some companies also offer vacation patrols and nighttime escort services.
Some groups form a nonprofit to collect money in advance from residents, and then enter into a single contract. Other neighborhoods, such as Maxwell Park, bargain collectively, after which each individual household enters into a contract with the security company.
The Maxwell Park neighborhood is a well-defined area of 1 square mile with about 2,400 homes and 7,000 residents, said Jose Dorado, one of the neighborhood's organizers. To date, 220 houses have entered into individual contracts with a private security company picked by the group. The group did extensive outreach, using neighborhood listservs, postcards and phone calls and walking door-to-door to gather support for the project.
Paul Liu, from lower Rockridge, had a different approach. After a string of crimes, culminating in the robberies of commuters at the casual carpool spot in his neighborhood, interest peaked for hiring private security, but his community wasn't organized, Liu said.
Liu turned to Crowdtilt, a web-based crowdfunding platform used to support a wide variety of activities, from disaster relief to political campaigns to startups. Within a couple of days, Liu had more than enough interest to fund a four-month trial with a private security provider.
"It helps to have a well-defined package to offer," Liu said.
Claire Cooper, a neighborhood organizer from the Laurel neighborhood, cautioned groups to shop carefully. Her group of 20 homes each paid $30 a month for Bay Alarm patrols to pass by four to six times a day at random hours. However, Cooper suspected that the patrols were occurring less frequently.
"They unilaterally reduced the patrols because we didn't have enough houses," Cooper said.
Cooper also said that crime rates skyrocketed in the area. The group is now looking for other services.
"We were too quick to run into the arms of Bay Alarm," Cooper said.
Bay Alarm customers can access logs for their area online to verify when their streets have been patrolled.
"We are part of the community. We are not just here to make money. I take every complaint seriously," said Limor Margalit, regional sales manager for Bay Alarm.
"It's a personal decision," said Bruce Stoffmacher, a community liaison for District 4 Councilmember Libby Schaaf's office. "One benefit of the process is that neighbors will get to know each other. That's positive."